Bucking The New Star Treatment

Martin Romjue
Posted on April 26, 2016


While sitting recently in a Marriott Residence Inn pondering how I could write about customer service problems, I opened up my Starbucks app and tapped to check my giant coffee cop full of gold stars. The cup was empty. A prompt said I was all up to date and there were no messages.

I admit I don’t read my Starbucks e-mail, so I rudely became aware of how the coffee house behemoth changed, or downgraded, its rewards program. As a gold card member, I used to get a free “reward” drink or item for every 12 stars earned. A gold star plopped into your app cup every time you bought one item, whether a coffee or a cake pop, regardless of price.

Now, the rewards are based on money spent, with two points for every dollar. Earn 125 points, and you get your reward. That means you pay $62.50 for every freebie. For those of us who spent anywhere from $1.75 to $5.75 on our qualifying 12 coffees, that’s a bad deal. Theoretically, you could buy 12 “tall” drip coffees at $1.75 each, for a total of $21, and then get a venti quad latte worth $5.75 for free.

What’s more, my gold card status now expires next month, instead of May 2017 based on all the stars I had earned under the old reward system.

Again, these are First World problems, but I e-mailed Starbucks, “outraged.” I got a nice form letter in response, detailing the rewards program, stating, “The new Starbucks Rewards is designed to give equal value to all of our members. The new program will reward your frequency AND the products you buy. We understand it may now take some customers longer to earn a Reward.”

Did they really say that? Translation: “We gave you a privilege for years of high frequency loyalty and spending, but now we’re taking a lot if it back, including one year’s worth of gold status.”

It’s pointless to argue with Starbucks. The corporate giant works out all of its P&Ls and market projection data to the finest degree, so I’m sure they see additional profit, or fewer lost revenues. I’m not surprised a downscaled Rewards program comes from a company that now tries to sell mediocre wines at $9 to $11 per glass, and that's just for the less mediocre brands. The finer mediocre brands cost more. 

Does Starbucks not realize you can likely find a better per-glass deal at multiple restaurants and bars within a three-mile radius in any urban or suburban area? Who would anyone buy a glass of wine at a Starbucks? Two-Buck Chuck smuggled in a used Starbucks cup would be a better deal. I’ve never even seen a glass being consumed at a local one that offers a wine menu. I can’t picture a group of five co-workers enjoying a post 5 p.m. happy hour of wine at $45 to $55 per round. (My God, that’s 90 to 110 stars!)

While Starbucks sees revenue growth, here’s what I saw one day after this discovery: Diagonally across the street from a Starbucks I regularly visit in Los Angeles on weekends, a new Dunkin' Donuts has opened. I look forward to switching from Starbucks brew to the smoother Dunkin’ one and swapping out my cake pops for donuts. Look! Watch me promote their website: DUNKIN' DONUTS

The point here is if you offer your clients rewards, discounts, privileges, benefits, extra amenities and/or perks as part of a continuing arrangement, don’t cheap out and dilute it. At least, clearly state at the beginning it’s a “limited time offer,” with a specific end date. Better yet, keep rewards membership constant.

So if you can’t maintain satisfaction in a long-term customer relationship, then you shouldn’t be pursuing one in the first place. You owe your clients respect, honesty and consistency. Competing providers once dismissed can start looking real good, real fast. Customers get mad when they realize you're just not that into them, and sure as hell won’t want to take your product anymore.

Related Topics: client feedback, client gifts, client markets, customer service, Sales & Marketing

Martin Romjue Editor
Comments ( 1 )
  • Eddie Rodrigues

     | about 3 years ago

    Speaking of stars... I love how you take a look at some of these reviews on Google and there are 50-100+ "5 star" reviews... I don't care how great your service is, there are always a few who can't be please no matter what you do. And those people are usually the ones that take the time to review. So when I ask my clients to please go to http://www.sanantoniotoplimo.com and click on the reviews to do it, it's amazing how many will if you just ask. They aren't all 5 star reviews, but really helps us out. We have many calls saying how they saw our reviews. What is your opinion of the reviews on Google, Yelp, etc?

More Stories
An ROI (return-on-investment) on a moving vehicle is easy to understand, but difficult to keep consistent. (LCT image)
Article

A Walk Through Coach Profits

NOV. LCT: These simple return-on-investment formulas will help you truly see if your buses of all sizes are making enough money.

Onboard intelligent tracking systems can document data for a wide range of motorcoach functions, such as engine status and maintenance, vehicle and driver performance, and driver hours, all while communicating pre-set and customized alerts and notifications in real-time.
Article

Driving More Dollar$ With Data

NOV. LCT: Product review - two leading systems provide a constant stream of information that can help operators wring out efficiencies.