The Greater Orlando Limousine Association held a festive meeting to close out the year.
Fund raising and letter writing could unite coachbuilders and operators.
After two years of being the only transportation industry subject to a gas guzzler penalty, it appears that 1993 will be the year in which livery operators learn whether or not an exemption can be created for commercial limousines. A lobbying plan has been commissioned by the Limousine Industry Manufacturers Organization (LIMO) and a decision on the plan is expected this spring. If a lobbying effort does take place, the industry will have its answer by year end. If it does not, the gas guzzler penalty would appear to be here to stay.
Limousines average approximately 19 miles per gallon which carries a penalty of $2,100 per vehicle. With more than 4,000 limousines purchased in the past two years, limousine buyers have paid over $8.4 million in gas guzzler penalties to date Jay Meyers, president of American Custom Coachworks, believes that the penalty steers buyers toward used limousines rather than new ones. He estimates that the penalty may have hurt industry sales by as much as 30 percent in 1992.
The current effort to lobby against the penalty began in the summer of 1992 when Meyers contributed $5,000 to fund a feasibility study on the issue by Washington, DC attorney Jeffrey Berger. LIMO contributed the balance of Berger’s $10,000 fee for the study which will be completed after Congress convenes this spring.
“In 1992, Congress passed a tax bill repealing the luxury tax on automobiles and boats,” explains Berger, “but President Bush didn’t sign it, so it never became law Another effort may be made to repeal the tax again this year and that’s the time to take action.” No action on taxes is expected until Congress receives its first tax proposal from the Clinton administration.
Berger has not yet outlined any specifics about how lobbying efforts might be pursued. He indicates, however, that potential changes in tax legislation will originate in the Senate Finance Committee and/or the House Ways and Means Committee The industry would presumably make its case to members of one or both of these committees
One argument expected to be used is that the gas guzzler penalty unfairly singles out the limousine industry for a fee that no other form of commercial transportation is subject to. It is also expected that the industry will document the negative economic impact of the penalty on limousine buyers and manufacturers. Another argument may be that the gas guzzler penalty has not had any positive effect on fuel consumption in the limousine industry.
It might also be argued that the cost of enforcing the penalty greatly offsets the revenue generated for the government. The cost of enforcement includes the auditing of limousine manufacturers by the Internal Revenue Service, and the administration of .an emissions certification program by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) (see related story on page 14).
Lobbying Could Cost $50,000
In 1986, Berger represented the National Limousine Association (NLA) in a lobbying effort which created a gas guzzler exemption for commercial limousines. This exemption was later repealed when the gas guzzler tax was instituted. Berger believes that a similar effort could now be successful. The cost of the previous campaign was $38,000 Projections for 1993 are as high as $50,000.
A majority of those contacted by Limousine & Chauffeur on this issue are pessimistic about chances for success. Some believe that the cost of a lobbying campaign is too great for the industry, and others feel that Congress will be unwilling to part with this revenue.
“I’ve become resigned to the fact we have to pay the gas guzzler penalty,” says Tom Mulligan of Metropolitan Limousine in Chicago. “I would be willing to contribute to a lobbying campaign,” he continues, “but I don’t know if this industry can afford to support an expensive program. It would need to be shared by operators and coach- builders “
Jerry Lottus, attorney for LIMO, believes a key to the effort will be finding a sponsor in Congress to support the issue “Once you have your ‘angel,’ you can encourage members of the industry to send him a letter of support with copies to their local Congress person.”‘
Even if the industry finds an “angel,” Lottus foresees resistance due to the perception that the gas guzzler penalty is passed on to affluent limousine users. “It will be tough to convince both houses of Congress that such a high profile industry should be exempt,” he says.
LIMO president Marsha Tortora agrees that the industry faces an uphill battle. “I doubt it will be rescinded,” she says. “LIMO really doesn’t have enough clout to fight this, but we are pursuing it on behalf of our customers.”
Tortora also believes that Berger’s feasibility study might identify contacts in Congress who can assist the industry on other issues “EPA requirements are becoming a tremendous problem,” she says.
Last October, NLA executive director Wayne Smith told board members that he sees little hope for a gas guzzler exemption “I don’t know what could make an exemption happen,” he told L&C The NLA board will review the matter again in January, but has determined not to fund a lobbying campaign unless there is a better prospect for success
But Meyers insists that a commercial exemption is justified since limousines carry an average of four to six people which makes them more fuel-efficient than private automobiles. “LIMO should do as much as possible on this,” he says, “and the NLA should be involved too. A lot of people are just rolling over and giving up It’s time we stood up on this.”
Industry Views on Gas Guzzler Penalty
“I’ve become resigned to the fact that we have to pay it, but it doesn’t seem right. I could understand it if it was my personal car”
— Tom Mulligan, Metropolitan Limousine. Chicago
The gas guzzler penalty encourages people to buy used limousines instead of new ones Eliminating the penalty would increase our sales 30 percent to 40 percent “
— Jay Movers. American Custom Coachworks
“We have committed $10,000 to creating an exemption, and we’re hoping the NLA will join us
—Beth Armstrong, executive director, Limousine Industry Manufacturer’s Organization
“The argument that there shouldn’t be a gas guzzler penalty on commercial transportation make;, the most sense The problem is that it appears the cost is passed on to high profile users.”
— Jerry Lottus, attorney. Limousine industry Manufacturer’s Organization.
“We have received a negative report on the probability of doing away with the gas guzzler We would be willing to contribute [to a lobbying effort] if results could be guaranteed “
— George Jacobs president, National Limousine Association
“I don’t know what could make an exemption happen I’ve discussed it with lobbyists and they’re not hopeful.”
—Wayne Smith, executive director, National Limousine Association.
“I doubt it will be rescinded, but we are pursuing it on behalf of our customers, and because we need to make the right connections to deal with other issues that are coming up ‘
—Marsha Tortera. Empire/Games Coach- builders, president. Limousine Industry Manufacturer’s Organization.
Leading Gas Guzzler States by Revenue
These figures are based on an average penalty of $2,100 per vehicle. The numbers are based on total sales since January 1 1991. Statistics provided by the L&C Research Department.
New York............................................. 630,000
The Greater Orlando Limousine Association held a festive meeting to close out the year.
The Limousine Safety Modernization Act would require modified passenger vehicles to follow the same rules as others.
Money raised will go toward producing a retreat and other causes the group advocates.
Authorities apply rigid rules and bust more illegal operators during the holiday season.
DEC. LCT: Motorcoach charter and tour services are suffering collateral damage as part of the city’s aggressive new rules.
The group raised more than $75,000 during its annual party at the Boomtown Brewery in downtown Los Angeles. Check out who all was there.
DEC. LCT Editor's Edge: The media has moved on from its mad mangle of a big story. Some of these points never got in their way.
The insurer canceled the policy six times this year for reasons that are not clear.
The family is seeking unspecified damages in state court from Prestige limousine service owner Shahed Hussain and his son.
More passengers want their own vehicle instead of taking public transit, shuttles, or personal vehicles parked off airport property.
Mears Transportation will allow its 600 taxis and 230 luxury vehicles to supply the TNC it once fiercely opposed.
Official admits to treating company involved in fatal Oct. 6 crash with "kid gloves."
10/23 update: As the public awaits a preliminary report on an accident cause, two recommendations after a 2015 crash would have affected the recent one.
Safety concerns with limousines are being tackled by politicians in Albany and Washington, D.C.
The TNC is lobbying the Seattle city government to levy tolls on area roadways during heavy traffic periods.
The world's No. 1 online marketplace and trader for professional chauffeured and chartered vehicles, including all types of motorcoaches, buses, vans, stretch limousines, sedans, SUVs, exotics, and classics. New and used vehicles are available from sellers across the nation.
The best online networker to find quality affiliates worldwide and market your company.
Click on any state to see the latest industry news and events in that region.