Vehicle Head-To-Head: Which luxury SUV is the better bang for your buck?
In the late 1990s, coachbuilders began making limousine buses almost as fast as stretch limousines. By the mid-2000s, all major coachbuilders were producing limo buses. Eventually, operators added shuttles, minibuses, and motorcoach charter tour buses to their fleets.
I was no exception. After more than a decade of running limo buses, I decided to take the next step in my fleet line-up and buy a motorcoach. An increasing number of operators have diversified into motorcoach service in recent years. [As a contributing editor of LCT Magazine, it also helps to have firsthand experience in Luxury Coach & Transportation, our formal name since January 2018]. In April 2011, we acquired a 55-passenger 2000 Setra S-217 motorcoach as part of a bus lease agreement with an unnamed company client.
The business path to a motorcoach in many ways resembles that of a limousine bus. My experience running a limo bus prepared me for the decision to take on a motorcoach.
In 1999, we jumped in head first into the bus market. It wasn’t very well thought out and at first caused great financial pain. The bus business can be lucrative on some days and dismal on others. A local competitor had bought the first limo bus in our area. Everyone who saw it loved it. Our clients began calling and asking if it was our vehicle or if we offered such a vehicle. I contacted the competitor to build a farm-out relationship. Because they were in a financial mess over this bus, they were eager for business regardless of where it came from and willing to work with me. This worked to my benefit. They billed me on terms of 30 days. This allowed me to farm it out to corporate accounts that had terms of 10 days to pay us.
We eventually bought the limo bus from our competitor, which went out of business.
Whether you plan to buy a limo bus, shuttle, or motorcoach, I suggest you first farm-out work to other companies in your area already running them to make sure you will get enough business. Once we got to the point where we were farming out five to eight jobs a month during a period of six months, it became apparent we should buy our own bus.
But the operation of any bus varies a lot from that of a limousine or sedan. You must be aware of laws that apply to buses and drivers, or you will pay huge fines. Ignorance is no excuse.
One of the first things you must consider is who will drive your bus. Bus drivers must hold a commercial driver’s license with a passenger and air-brake endorsement (if equipped). In some states, the cost of a commercial driver’s license far exceeds that of a standard driver’s license. In other states, no special license is required to drive a limousine for hire, but the federal Department of Transportation regulates buses in all states. Many states also regulate buses through a state DOT agency with respect to passenger safety.
Bus drivers are required to maintain logbooks for trips that travel beyond a certain radius from your base of operations. I hired a bus driver from a charter bus company to provide knowledge and guidance in training new drivers to operate our bus. There are federal DOT laws pertaining to drug and alcohol testing and how it must be administered. Having an experienced person provide guidance can spare you huge fines levied by state and federal authorities for violations. Logbooks are examined by both state and federal DOT inspectors. By hiring experienced bus drivers, it is presumed that they know right from wrong and what needs to be done to remain legal. Don’t become a training ground for new drivers.
When you begin shopping for a bus, you may want to consider buying a used bus first. It will save you money. Buses are built for high-mileage highway driving and can roll for long intervals without much maintenance. Because the price of a bus is so high, whether you buy new or used, financing terms can be spread over a longer period of time. A 55-passenger used coach can cost up to $250,000, but the payments can be spread over a 10-year period. However, you must calculate if you may wear out the bus before the final pay off based on the distance radius within which you plan to provide service.
Going through a federal DOT inspection can be a nerve-racking and grueling experience. Steve Levin of Sterling Rose Transportation in Carlsbad, Calif., went through a difficult two-day inspection where he learned firsthand about laws that were being unintentionally broken, but fineable offenses just the same.
I learned a painful lesson when one of our limo buses was seen by a federal DOT agent crossing the California-Nevada border. Who knew they take photos as you pass a border? You do now. I was unaware that you must have federal DOT authority to be able to drive across that imaginary line. A fine of $1,600 was assessed for my ignorance. But the inspector was quite helpful in getting us properly licensed.
Levin and I learned that driver qualification files must be kept under lock and key at all times. Failure to keep them in a locked cabinet with restricted access will result in a fine. Driver qualification files must include documentation of a road test, drug and alcohol test results, previous employer verification, a copy of a medical examiner’s card, a copy of the driver’s license, and a recent copy of the driver’s motor vehicle record. Buses in California are routinely stopped by “commercial enforcement officers” who will check the mechanical condition of the bus and the logbook of your driver.
Electronic logging devices (required as of 2018) are critical in documenting “hours of service” of your driver. There are rules about how many hours your driver can be on the road in a day and how many hours he can legally be on the clock while not driving. Buses must go through an annual safety inspection each year. Meanwhile, your recordkeeping will be put through a test in what is known as a “terminal inspection.” Any violation found may result in a fine.
Unlike your $29.95 Jiffy Lube special, a routine oil change can run $150-$250. There are all types of filters to change on a bus. Diesel engines can go 6,000 to 10,000 miles between oil changes depending on idling time and driving time. If you buy a used bus, one of the first major components that may fail you is the turbocharger. Expect to pay $1,700-$2,000 for a replacement. A tire for your bus can easily cost $400-$600. This does not include the price of installation. If your bus should break down, you will need a heavy-duty wrecker, and even a short tow across town can cost $300. A tune-up can run as much as $600.
A full-size bus generally won’t fit the pump area of your local gas station. You will need to go to a commercial truck stop for fuel. You might want to consider a commercial fueling program because you will buy a lot of fuel at one time. A full size coach can hold 250 gallons of fuel. If you’re on empty, it will cost about $1,000 to fill up. If your waste tank is full, you will probably need to find another location to dump your waste tank such as an RV facility. Some locations charge for allowing you to empty your holding tank at their facility.
Charter and tour bus companies generally charge by the mile and limousine companies by the hour. Calculate your payment and insurance costs first. Divide that by anticipated monthly charter hours. This is the hourly rate you must charge only to cover fixed expenses. Five hours each Friday and Saturday is about 40 hours a month. If your payment and insurance are $4,300, you need to earn at least $107.50 for each hour your bus works. The rest of the expenses vary with each trip depending on driver wages and fuel expense. You also must include enough money to cover tune-ups, tire replacement, and oil changes during the year.
Editor's note: Updated on 5/17/18 with new links and recent related articles at end of story.
Cost to “make ready”
13 washes/prep by detailer — $10/hour x 13 hours = $130
Driver wages (including pre/post trip) — $15/hour x 104 hours = $1,560
Fuel — 263 Gallons @ $3.80 = $999.40
Insurance (monthly premium) = $342
Monthly vehicle payment = $3,942
Oil change ($150 per 6,000 miles) — .025 per mile x 1,450 = $36.25
Tire replacement — ($450 per 100,000 miles).0045 per mile x 1,450 = $39.18**
Major tune-up — ($600 per 75,000 miles) .008 per mile x 1450 = $11.60
TOTAL BREAK-EVEN POINT = $7,060.43
Excludes employer payroll tax or workers’ comp premium
**Based on six tires
$7,060.43 / by 78 hours of service = rate of $90.51 per hour OR
$7,060.43 / 1,450 miles = $4.87 per mile
With 10% profit margin: $100 per hour OR $5.36 per mile
Bus fuel capacity: 50 to 250 gallons
Average MPG: 4 to 9 mpg
Average fill-up cost: $185 — $925
Commercial truck stop required for large buses
Tire replacement: $400 — $600 each
Lube, oil and filter service: $150 — $250
Turbo replacement (diesel): $1,500 — $2,000
Minimum: $5 million liability required
Monthly cost: $280 — $500
National average hourly pay
School bus drivers: $10.19 — $18.32
Transit bus drivers: $9.57 — $23.09
Greyhound Bus Lines: $15 — $20.67
Related Topics: bus market, buses, California operators, cost efficiencies, cost savings, DOT issues, driver safety, federal regulations, fleet insurance, fleet management, group transportation, How To, maintenance, motorcoach operators, motorcoaches, New Operator
Vehicle Head-To-Head: Which luxury SUV is the better bang for your buck?
Vehicle Pick of the Week: This shuttle radiates quality and saves on overhead costs.
Built by INKAS Armored, the vehicle meets CEN 1063 BR6 ballistic standards and provides protection for fuel, battery, and electronic control unit compartments.
Industry dealers have booked final orders for a last wave of sales on this decade’s flagship luxury limousine vehicle.
Vehicle Pick of the Week: While black executive vans are popular, brides and ballers may prefer a more distinct vehicle.
Vehicle Review: The crossover gives new meaning to the idea of “Quiet Flight."
The luxury sedan's production will yield to two electrical vehicle models scheduled for the Flat Rock plant.
Seven out of the best 10 selling high-end vehicles last year were CUVs or SUVs.
Vehicle Review: The luxury sedan's semi-autonomous function is by far its most impressive feature.
Add one more uncertainty about autonomous vehicles: How do you get them to drive like locals?
Vehicle Pick of the Week: The upscale van is laid out like a stretch, except with more room and amenities.
But make sure your beneficiaries can handle the electrified rates.
Three of these venerable vehicles are former limousine/ livery industry stalwarts.
Vehicle Review: Strong engine performance vaults the green SUV into the luxury vehicle space category.
Vehicle Review: Cutting-edge infotainment and driver assist tech are just a few reasons this lux sedan rises to the top.
The world's No. 1 online marketplace and trader for professional chauffeured and chartered vehicles, including all types of motorcoaches, buses, vans, stretch limousines, sedans, SUVs, exotics, and classics. New and used vehicles are available from sellers across the nation.
The best online networker to find quality affiliates worldwide and market your company.
Click on any state to see the latest industry news and events in that region.