New York Operators Fight Aggressive TLC Vehicle Seizures

Posted on May 29, 2013

Joseph Scifo, a representative from the New York City Drivers Assistance Corporation, speaks to LILA members as the LILA board looks on.
Joseph Scifo, a representative from the New York City Drivers Assistance Corporation, speaks to LILA members as the LILA board looks on.

PLAINVIEW, NY— Members of the Long Island Limousine Association (LILA) have seen a drastic rise recently in the number of chauffeured vehicles seized by the New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission (TLC). Many of these seizures are based on unfounded claims of illegal point-to-point service within New York City, LILA leaders said. Association members are based mostly in Suffolk and Nassau Counties but make frequent trips into New York City for drop-offs and pick-ups.

To inform membership on the problem, LILA invited Joseph Scifo, a representative from the New York City Drivers Assistance Corporation, an organization which offers legal representation for TLC summonses, to speak at its May membership meeting.

Several LILA operators claim their drivers have been unfairly stopped and intimidated by TLC officers. Second vice president Matt Silver of Ultimate Class Limousines has had two vehicles impounded by the NYC TLC.

“Both experiences have been very unpleasant,” Silver said. The TLC officer threatened to arrest his chauffeur, even presenting handcuffs, if he did not comply. Feeling intimidated, the chauffeur began to answer questions and eventually the vehicles were impounded.

“What we were doing wasn’t wrong,” Silver said. “I asked for a supervisor to report to the scene but was told, ‘You’re too late. We’ve already called the tow truck.’”

Silver feels the TLC is seizing vehicles unlawfully in the hopes that operators will settle the issue by paying fees instead of incurring the greater costs of contesting the seizure and loss of vehicle use.

Scifo supported this claim. “They’re seizing vehicles left and right,” he said. The TLC is ignoring a reciprocity agreement which allows operators in other municipalities or states to cross borders for continuous trips, he said. (For example, a New Jersey operator transporting a client from New Jersey to JFK or a New York City operator taking a client from Manhattan to Newark.)

During a traffic stop, TLC officers will try to establish that the chauffeur is conducting a point-to-point job, and will often question the passengers separately, fishing for sufficient information to make a seizure, Scifo said. “They are taking to the extreme and basically saying, ‘Prove it to the judge.’”

Additionally, Scifo said that hearings are typically scheduled for the maximum 15 days from seizure to increase vehicle storage fees and loss-of-use costs.

Members of the Limousine Associations of New Jersey have reported similar experiences in recent months.

LILA will investigate what legal options they may have to contest TLC seizures and operators’ rights when dealing with TLC officers.

Repealing NY Limo Tax
LILA leadership is also rallying the association to support the current effort to repeal limo sales tax in New York State. Similar bills to this effect have been introduced in the New York State Senate and Assembly. LILA President Robert Cunningham of Platinum Limousine urged member operators to contact their local Assembly representatives and Senators to show their support for the repeal and communicate the burden the sales tax puts on small businesses.

Additional information on the effort and contact information for state representatives can be found here.

Related article: RECIPROCITY: Operators Gain Mobility In NYC Area

Related article: Targeting Town Cars: NY Ticketeers Feed Their Frenzy

— Denis Wilson, LCT East Coast Editor

View comments or post a comment on this story. (9 Comments)

More News

Don't Ask About Pay History If You're Hiring In NYC

A bill makes it illegal to use an applicant’s past wages to determine what salary and/or benefits to offer.

This Heartland City Now Lets Taxis Operate Like TNCs

Cabs under Yellow Cab and 10/10 Taxi will shift to zTrip, a TNC subject to the same state licensing standards as Uber and Lyft.

Should Local Governments Regulate Uber?

A Florida law would require TNCs to have $1 million in insurance coverage whenever their drivers are doing a run.

Party Bus Involved In Shootings Was Illegal, Feds Say

The vehicle the victims were riding in April 22 isn’t allowed to operate according to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration.

TNCs Become Legal Statewide Under NY State Budget

Uber and Lyft operate in New York City under a 2001 arrangement through existing taxi laws that will not change. 

See More News

Facebook Comments ()

Comments (9)

Post a Comment



See More

LCT Store

LCT Magazine - April 2017 $12.95 F&I / SPECIAL EVENTS ISSUE COVER STORY: * Don't Panic: Confronting Worst Fears - Fleet Risks * *


Experience the three annual industry events for networking for business, showcasing vehicles and products, and getting the tools for success.

Read About Your Region

What’s Happening Near You?
Click on any state to see the latest industry news and events in that region.

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment


Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Metro Magazine

Serving the bus and passenger rail industries for more than a century

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

Please sign in or register to .    Close