Bell Trans Heads To Mediation In Wage Dispute

Posted on February 24, 2010 by LCT Staff - Also by this author - About the author

Attorneys disclose session scheduled for Saturday to bring both sides together to resolve pay issues for Bell’s Las Vegas chauffeurs.

LAS VEGAS, Nev. — Bell Transportation, the largest transportation company in Nevada, heads to mediation on Saturday after being embroiled in a chauffeur labor lawsuit for nearly at year. The attorney representing the chauffeurs, Mark Thierman, has setup a mediation session to be held Saturday in Las Vegas.

The session will include the plaintiffs specifically named in the lawsuit as well as Bell's attorney, Norman Kirshman. Also participating will be President and CEO Brent Bell and key Bell executives Chip Bell, Lynn Vlahos, and Mark Trafton, Thierman said.

The 10 a.m. meeting is the latest effort to resolve pay issues between Bell Transportation and its chauffeurs. Kirshman on Wednesday called the atmosphere going into the mediation session very good. He acknowledged that both attorneys in the matter are "very sophisticated with these matters," and in a nod to Thierman, Kirshman said, "He has an unbelievably good resume in this type of case.”

Kirshman said the mediator in the case is one of the best in the country: Michael Dickstein, who teaches at Stanford University and has previously mediated cases involving both attorneys with successful results.

The main issue stems from Bell's alleged failure to pay chauffeurs for time spent looking for clients by trolling the cities airport and casinos. Bell pays chauffeurs on a per-job basis but yet acknowledges they are employees by bumping up their pay last July to coincide with a Nevada minimum wage increase. The chauffeurs have used that to their advantage, stating that the mere fact they are paid minimum wage indicates that Bell acknowledges them as employees and not contractors.

LCT previously reported that a federal judge issued a ruling in a class action lawsuit filed by Bell chauffeurs determining that chauffeurs could not legally sue for minimum wages. Bell chauffeurs are sent out scouting for prospective passengers during their assigned shift but do not get paid for their efforts. They get paid only while providing service.

Bell Trans responded in the lawsuit that chauffeurs are “like” independent sales representatives who should be compensated based on productivity rather than receiving a guaranteed hourly wage.

The chauffeurs say they are entitled to the same pay most other workers receive, and claim that sitting in a car in front of a hotel waiting for someone to engage their service is work at the pleasure of the company and therefore worthy of compensation. It is no different than an office worker who is paid while waiting for an assignment or even a fast food cashier who is paid while waiting for the next customer to walk in the door.

According to Kirshman, Bell sees the merit in settling the case before having to address legal issues in court. Kirshman has represented Bell through two generations of ownership and believes a settlement will be reached during the mediation session on Saturday which is closed to the public.

From Bell’s standpoint, the most important matter on the table is having the chauffeurs accept the Motor Carrier Exemption Act, which in Kirshman’s opinion, applies to all chauffeurs employed by Bell. The Act specifically addresses the fact that chauffeurs engaged in interstate transportation and are exempt from overtime. Removing this single issue from the equation, Kirshman says, "would take a huge amount of liability out of the case and facilitate settlement."

Bell’s position is that since most of the passengers it serves arrive at McCarran International Airport from another state, the passengers are engaged in "interstate travel” because they are involved in "the flow of commerce" by booking their hotel rooms from out-of-state points, Kirshman said. Chauffeurs should be subject to the rules of the U.S. Department of Transportation, which has jurisdiction over interstate travel and created overtime rules in the 1970s.

Kirshman also cited the case of Baldonado vs. Wynn in which a court already ruled that labor issues fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Nevada Labor Commissioner and not the court system. The chauffeurs have an appeal pending on their case before the San Francisco Court of Appeals.

— Jim Luff, LCT Contributing Editor

View comments or post a comment on this story. (3 Comments)

More News

European Court May Derail Uber

Recommendation to classify the TNC a transportation company rather than digital platform could stifle growth.

Florida Governor Signs Landmark TNC Legislation

The new law requires $1 million in insurance coverage when transporting a passenger and third party driver background checks.

Philly Operators Maintain Opposition To Vehicle Fee

Despite the assessment being reduced from $856 to $500, operators argue the cost is still burdesome.

ABA Members Lobby Congress During Annual Fly-In Event

Motorcoach operators from around the country convened May 3-4 to talk priority issues.

Justice Department Opens Criminal Probe Into Uber

The investigation is in its early stages, but deepens the crisis for the embattled company and its CEO Travis Kalanick.

See More News

Facebook Comments ()

Comments (3)

Post a Comment



See More

LCT Store

LCT Magazine - May 2017 $12.95 Post International LCT Show Issue COVER STORY: * Best Operators of 2017: Their Winning Secrets Revealed * *


Experience the three annual industry events for networking for business, showcasing vehicles and products, and getting the tools for success.

Read About Your Region

What’s Happening Near You?
Click on any state to see the latest industry news and events in that region.

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher

Automotive Fleet

The Car and truck fleet and leasing management magazine

Business Fleet

managing 10-50 company vehicles

Fleet Financials

Executive vehicle management

Government Fleet

managing public sector vehicles & equipment


Work Truck Magazine

The number 1 resource for vocational truck fleets

Metro Magazine

Serving the bus and passenger rail industries for more than a century

Schoolbus Fleet

Serving school transportation professionals in the U.S. and Canada

Please sign in or register to .    Close